The Influencer-Investor Phenomenon: Beyond Brand Deals

Experts identify five key values creators bring to brands: influence, credibility, conversion rates, impressions, and creative input. While some creators excel in one area, others contribute across all five. The initial step for brands is to discern which of these values a creator genuinely offers.

When a creator's impact is measurable, a standard brand deal might only capture a small portion of their overall contribution to a business. It can be considered unfair if a creator's involvement ends with a fixed campaign fee, while others continue to benefit from the enduring value they've generated.

This is why influencers might opt for equity in a company over a traditional brand agreement. However, brands must assess if the influencer's business value aligns with specific, desired outcomes. It's crucial to understand precisely where the influencer's impact is intended to be felt – whether in product development, opening new distribution channels, reaching new audiences, or strengthening relationships with existing customers. The partnership between a startup and an influencer needs to be sustainable over time. True long-term alignment, where an influencer's past trajectory matches the brand's core mission, is essential for them to support the company through both prosperous and challenging periods.

Once this alignment is established, equity can significantly reshape the dynamic between influencers and brands. Unlike paid partnerships with fixed deliverables, a talent investor whose potential earnings are tied to key performance indicators (KPIs) can foster greater synergy and adaptability as the company's needs change.

Crucial Consideration: Can the Startup Thrive Independently?

Regardless of how well an influencer fits the business model, their influence alone cannot overcome fundamental business weaknesses. It's imperative to believe that the business has the potential to succeed on its own, with the influencer's involvement serving as an additional advantage. From the perspective of a consumer investor, an influencer's participation should only accelerate a business that is already viable, rather than forming the core of its business model.

This principle may explain why many prominent influencer investments are concentrated in the beverage and supplement sectors. For example, several investments have been made in drink brands and supplement companies. Similarly, a lifestyle influencer became an investor and co-owner of a drink company, which was later acquired for a substantial sum by a larger beverage corporation. Other notable portfolios also include beverage and wellness brands.

Photo: Getty Images